Skip to content
JOH Partners
Advisory Board vs Board of Directors: When a Gulf Group Needs One

Subscribe to our newsletter

A standing brief on the executive search and leadership market across the Gulf.

Research, market notes and pay benchmarks, direct to your inbox. Every two weeks. No marketing. Unsubscribe anytime.

An advisory board is a group of outside advisers who counsel a company's owners and management but hold no vote, owe no directors' duties and cannot bind the company. A board of directors can do all three. For Gulf family groups, the advisory board is often the first attempt at independent challenge, because it lets the family hear outside views without handing over control. JOH Partners, which has worked with family groups and their boards since 2014, sees it succeed when the family treats it as a stage with a date to become a board. It fails when it becomes a place to keep respected outsiders whose advice nobody is obliged to take.

Two neighbouring questions are covered elsewhere. JOH's perspective on appointing a non-executive director deals with a single board appointment, and JOH's research on family governance in Gulf family groups deals with family councils, charters and where they meet the board. This piece is about the choice that comes before both: whether a family group needs advice or a board, and how to tell when the first has quietly become a substitute for the second.

What is an advisory board, and what can it not do?

An advisory board is usually set up by the owner or the group chief executive. Its members are appointed by letter, paid a fee and asked to meet a few times a year. They review the strategy, a market entry, a technology plan or the case for an acquisition. Good advisory boards include people the family could never hire full time: a retired bank chief executive, an industrialist from another market, a specialist in the family's next line of business.

What it cannot do is decide. It does not approve the accounts, appoint or remove the chief executive, set a dividend or sign a contract. Its members do not owe the duties a director owes to the company, and they do not carry a director's liability. That is the attraction on both sides. The family keeps every decision, and the adviser gives a view without signing anything.

The line is not purely a matter of title. English company law has a name for the adviser who crosses it. Section 251 of the Companies Act 2006 defines a shadow director as a person in accordance with whose directions or instructions the directors are accustomed to act, and it excludes advice given in a professional capacity. Gulf jurisdictions have their own rules, and a family should take local advice on how its own law treats the same situation. The practical point holds anywhere: whether a body advises or directs depends on how it behaves, not on what it is called.

Advisory board vs board of directors: what changes when advice becomes a vote

The legal differences are easy to list. The practical ones matter more to a family deciding which it needs.

Figure 01FIG-01

Advisory board and board of directors compared

QuestionAdvisory boardBoard of directors
Who appoints the members?The owner or chief executive, by letterThe shareholders, under the articles and the companies law
What can it decide?Nothing; it advisesThe matters the law and the articles give it, including the accounts and the chief executive
Who does it answer to?Whoever appointed itThe company and its shareholders
What information does it see?What management chooses to show itWhat it needs to discharge its duties, and it can ask for more
What happens when it disagrees?The family can set the view asideThe disagreement is minuted and has to be resolved
Figure 01. A general comparison. The legal position depends on the company's jurisdiction and its articles, and a family group should take local advice.Source · JOH Partners, November 2026

The last row is the one that matters most. A board's disagreement has consequences. It is recorded, it can stop a decision and, in a listed company, it can reach the shareholders. An advisory board's disagreement can be heard politely and forgotten. For a family that wants challenge without risk, that is exactly the appeal. For a family that needs challenge, it is the weakness.

Information is the second difference, and it is often underestimated. Directors ask for papers. Advisers are shown presentations. A group whose advisers have only ever seen the divisional heads' slides has not tested whether its outsiders would ask the questions a board would.

Why do Gulf family groups start with an advisory board?

Control is the first reason, and it is a fair one. The family built the business and carries the risk. It wants outside views without giving outsiders a vote on the chief executive or the dividend. An advisory board gives it that.

Trust is the second, and in JOH's observation it is the best reason. A family rarely gives a vote to someone it does not know. An advisory board lets the family see how an outsider thinks, how they behave when they disagree and whether they keep a confidence, before the family decides whether to make them a director. On the JOH podcast, Hussein Wehbe on influence, culture and continuous learning, who now serves on several advisory boards, talks about leading through influence rather than position. An adviser has no position at all, so how much an advisory board achieves depends on whether its members earn the family's trust.

The third reason is the next generation. Some families use an advisory board to expose their children to senior outsiders before they take a board role themselves. That works if the children are in the room and asked for their view.

The legal setting helps explain the choice. JOH's research on family governance found that the Gulf's statutory family business tools are designed mainly for private family companies, and that listed family groups have a charter or a council only to the extent that they have written one themselves. An advisory board sits outside all of those frameworks. It is a private arrangement, which is why it is easy to set up and just as easy to ignore.

When does an advisory board work as a stepping stone?

The advisory boards that work in the groups JOH advises share a few habits. None of them is complicated.

They have a written purpose and a date. A family might decide that within two years two of its advisers will be invited to join the board as independent directors, or that the advisory board will close. The date changes how everyone behaves. The family knows it is choosing future directors. The advisers know they are being assessed.

The members are chosen as people the family would be willing to have as directors. That rules out the friend of the founder who is good company, and the famous name who will attend twice a year. It points instead to people with the time, the independence and the experience a future board will need. JOH's perspective on board refreshment and the five-year mix is a useful frame here: the advisory board is the first chance to build the mix the board will need in five years.

There is a sponsor in the family who takes the advice back, and who reports at the next meeting what was done with it. Advice that disappears teaches advisers to stop giving it.

Papers go out before the meeting, and the minutes record both the advice and the family's response. That record is what lets the family, and later the board, see whether the advisers were right.

An advisory board works when the family has already decided it will have a real board and wants time to get there. Without that decision, it is a group of able people whose advice nobody has to take.
— Oliver Helvin, Founder and Managing Director

When does it become a substitute for a board?

The signs are usually visible from outside. The advisory board has no end date. Its members are renewed by habit, and some have served for a decade. It meets to hear presentations rather than to discuss papers. The serious matters, such as who succeeds the chief executive, a large acquisition or a dealing with a family-owned supplier, never reach it. The advisers learn about decisions after they are made.

The most serious sign is how the family describes the body to others. When a group tells a lender, a co-investor or a regulator that its advisory board provides independent oversight, it is asking outsiders to rely on something that has no power to oversee. That can work until the day it is tested. JOH's research on the new mandate for chairs in Gulf-listed family businesses, drawn from sixty GCC family-controlled listed companies, sets out the shifts a board must make to stay credible to capital, and an advisory board standing in for one is not among them.

Not every advisory body is a failed board. A group with a real board may keep a technical panel on a new sector, or a regional council for a market it is entering. A private group with no outside capital and no plan to raise it may need advice and nothing more. The question is not whether to have an advisory board. It is whether the family is using it to avoid a decision about governance that it will one day have to make.

The simplest test of an advisory board is to ask when its advice last changed a decision the family had already made.
— Oliver Helvin, Founder and Managing Director

A composite: five years of advice and no directors

The details are changed and combined from several situations. This is not any one client's story.

A second-generation group runs trading, property and food manufacturing businesses. The founder's eldest son, now group chief executive, sets up an advisory board of four: a retired bank chief executive, a former strategy consultant, an industrial chief executive from another Gulf market and a university professor. It meets three times a year. The divisional heads present, the discussion is good and the family values it.

In the fourth year the group agrees a large acquisition. The advisers hear about it after it is signed. In the fifth year a lender asks, as a condition of refinancing, for independent directors on the board of the main operating company. The family turns to its advisers. Two have no wish to take on a director's duties. One is now a director of a company that supplies the group, which rules him out. The fourth agrees, but the family has never seen him chair anything.

The group runs a search for independent directors with a deadline set by its lender. Five years of advice had produced no director the family was ready to appoint, because nobody had said that producing one was the point.

How does a family group move from advisory board to board?

Start with the decisions, not the people. Write down which decisions will belong to the board: the budget, the appointment of the chief executive, significant related-party dealings, acquisitions above a set size. Put them in the articles or a board charter, so that the board's authority does not depend on goodwill.

Then choose the advisers the family would trust with a vote, and invite them formally, with a letter of appointment, a term and, where it fits, a committee role. JOH's perspective on the non-executive director role sets out what the role demands of the person who takes it. Recruit at least one independent director from outside the advisory group, so the new board is not the old advisory board renamed. And brief the family members who will sit as directors on what changes for them. Their duties change too.

A new board also needs information its advisory body never had. It needs a continuing view of the executive layer and of who could succeed the chief executive. Platforms such as Board Pulse are built to give a board that view, so its first succession discussion rests on evidence and not on the family's impressions.

The prize is a board that can carry a decision the family could not make alone. JOH's engagement placing the first non-family chief executive into a Saudi industrial group shows what is at stake when a family group reaches that point. The group holdings sector page sets out where JOH sees these structures most often.

A family group weighing that move has two practical next steps. It can book a Board Pulse demo to see the evidence on its executive layer that a new board will expect from its first meeting. Or it can engage a partner at JOH Partners to talk through which of its advisers should become directors, and where the independent ones should come from.

Frequently asked questions

Questions about this topic.

What is an advisory board?

An advisory board is a group of outside advisers who counsel a company's owners and management. Its members are usually appointed by letter, paid a fee and asked for views on strategy, markets or technology. Unlike directors, they hold no vote, cannot bind the company and do not take on the legal duties and liability that come with a directorship.

What is the difference between an advisory board and a board of directors?

A board of directors has legal authority over the company: it approves the accounts, appoints the chief executive and answers to shareholders, and its members owe duties to the company. An advisory board gives advice that the owners can take or leave. In practice the most important difference is consequence: when a board disagrees, the disagreement is recorded and has to be dealt with, while an advisory board's view can be set aside without trace.

When should a Gulf family group set up an advisory board?

In JOH Partners' observation, an advisory board is most useful when a family has decided to build an independent board and wants time to get to know outside people before giving them a vote. It works best with a written purpose, a sponsor in the family and a date by which some advisers will be invited to join the board or the advisory body will close.

Can advisory board members become liable as directors?

It depends on the law of the company's jurisdiction and on how the advisers behave. English company law, for example, defines a shadow director as a person in accordance with whose directions or instructions the directors are accustomed to act, with an exception for advice given in a professional capacity. A family group should take local advice on how its own jurisdiction treats advisers who in practice give instructions.

How does a family group move from an advisory board to a board of directors?

Decide which decisions will belong to the board, such as the budget, the chief executive's appointment and significant related-party dealings, and write them down. Invite the advisers the family would trust with a vote, with a formal letter of appointment and a term. Then recruit at least one independent director from outside the advisory group, so the new board is not simply the old advisory body renamed.

Author

Oliver Helvin

Founder and Managing Director

Oliver Helvin is the Founder and Managing Director of JOH Partners. He writes on the GCC executive market, leadership transitions in family-controlled businesses, and the discipline of senior search.

LinkedIn ↗