Skip to content
JOH Partners
Succession Planning for the Executive Committee on Gulf Boards

Subscribe to our newsletter

A standing brief on the executive search and leadership market across the Gulf.

Research, market notes and pay benchmarks, direct to your inbox. Every two weeks. No marketing. Unsubscribe anytime.

Succession planning for the executive committee is the part of succession that most Gulf boards leave unwritten. Most can name a successor for the chief executive, or say that the family will decide. Few can name who would cover the chief financial officer for a month, who would run the largest business if its head resigned, or which of their senior team is ready for a bigger job within two years. The Saudi Capital Market Authority's Corporate Governance Regulations ask boards to develop succession plans for the management of the company. This piece sets out what a plan beneath the chief executive should contain, and where Gulf boards usually fall short. In JOH Partners' earlier research on sixty family-controlled listed companies, 47 expected a succession event at chief executive or chair level within five years, and only 14 had a documented internal successor whose name the board could give.

What a Gulf board usually means by succession planning

Ask a chair whether the board has a succession plan and the answer is usually yes. Ask what it contains and the answers narrow quickly. In JOH Partners' observation, three versions are common.

The first is a name for the chief executive, often a family member or a long-serving deputy, held in the chair's head and not written anywhere. The second is a document produced for the regulator or the lender, updated when someone asks. The third is a list of internal names with no assessment against the job, built by the human resources team from the organisation chart.

None of these is dishonest. They are the plan a board has time for. The trouble is that each is refreshed only when something happens: a resignation, a health scare, a regulatory request. By then the board is choosing under pressure with whatever information it has. A succession plan that is first read on the day it is needed is a list of hopes.

What the rules ask of the board

The rules are clearer than the practice. The Saudi Capital Market Authority's Corporate Governance Regulations, in the English translation reviewed for this piece, place succession work in three places.

Figure 01FIG-01

What the Saudi Corporate Governance Regulations say about succession

ArticleWho it addressesWhat it asks
Article 24(8)The boardTo develop succession plans for the management of the company
Article 28(8)Each board memberTo take part in developing the succession and replacement plans for executive positions
Article 62(5), (6) and (9)The nomination committeeTo review each year the skills the board and executive management need, to review the structure of both, and to set the procedures to follow when a board or senior executive position falls vacant
Figure 01. The table paraphrases the English translation of the regulations as amended in 2023. The Arabic text is the official text, and some paragraphs are marked as guiding. A company should read the current official text and take local advice.Source · Saudi Capital Market Authority, Corporate Governance Regulations (English translation); JOH Partners reading

Three points follow. The duty sits with the whole board and with each director, not with the human resources function. The language is about management and executive positions in the plural, not the chief executive alone. And the nomination committee is asked for the procedure for a vacancy, which is the written answer to the question "what happens on the day".

Other Gulf codes handle this differently, and a group should read its own market's rules. The point for a board is that a plan beneath the chief executive is not an extra. In at least one major market it is written into the code.

Most boards cannot name who would run the group's biggest business if its head resigned tomorrow. A succession plan that cannot answer that question is a list of names, and it will not help on the day.
— Oliver Helvin, Founder and Managing Director

One name for the chief executive is not a bench

The earlier research is a reminder of the scale. JOH Partners' report on the succession gap in GCC family groups found that of sixty family-controlled listed companies in the firm's corpus, forty-seven expected a succession event at chief executive or chair level within five years. Only fourteen had a documented internal successor whose name the board could give, with the candidate's awareness.

47 of 60. GCC family-controlled listed companies in JOH's earlier corpus that expect a succession event at chief executive or chair level within five years

JOH Partners, The Succession Gap, edition 2 of the research series.

14 of 60. Companies in the same corpus with a documented internal successor whose name the board could give, with the candidate's awareness

JOH Partners, The Succession Gap, edition 2 of the research series.

That research looked at the top of the house. The pattern beneath it is, in JOH Partners' observation, no better and often worse, because nobody is looking. A chief executive can be a stated priority for a chair. A head of a division, a group general counsel or a chief financial officer rarely is, and the people in those roles are usually the ones a rival or a regulator notices first.

A board that has one name for the chief executive and none beneath has a plan for one day out of several hundred.

Three names for every critical role

A useful plan names people for three different situations, and the three are not the same people.

The first is the emergency cover: who runs the role tomorrow morning if the holder is gone. This is often the holder's own deputy, or a peer from another division, and it needs no skills assessment. It needs a name and a conversation, so the person knows and the holder knows.

The second is the interim: who could run the role for up to a year while the board finds a permanent holder. This is a harder question, because an interim has to be credible with the team and with outside parties such as banks, regulators and the largest customers. In some roles the right interim is an external appointment, and the board should know which executive search firm or interim provider it would call, and how fast.

The third is the planned successor: who the board is preparing to take the role permanently, over a period of one to three years. This is where assessment, development and exposure to the board belong. It is also the name that should be tested against the outside market before the board commits to it.

A role is critical, for this purpose, if its sudden loss would stop something the group cannot do without: a licence, a lender's covenant, a regulator's approval, the largest customer relationship, the audit. The chief financial officer, the general counsel, the chief operating officer and the heads of the two or three largest businesses usually qualify. The list should be short, written down and agreed by the board, and not a copy of the organisation chart.

A chair should be able to say, in one breath, who covers each critical role. If it takes a document and an afternoon, the board does not yet have a plan.
— Oliver Helvin, Founder and Managing Director

What a readiness rating should show the board

Once a board has the names, it needs to see how ready they are. Readiness ratings go wrong in two ways. Either they are too soft, with every internal candidate rated as ready in a year, or they are kept so private that the board cannot see how they change.

A rating that helps a board is simple and comes with evidence. It says whether the person is ready now, ready in one to two years, or not yet identified, and it says why, using something the board can check: a result delivered, an acting appointment held, a view from someone who has worked with the person at close range. It is refreshed at least once a year. And what the board sees is the movement: who has moved up since last year, who has dropped back, which roles still have no name.

The chief people officer normally keeps the evidence, and the case for that is made in JOH Partners' perspective on the CHRO and the board's line of sight. The rating itself should be agreed by the chief executive and the chair together, not self-assessed by the executive and not left to the human resources team alone.

Benchmark before an internal name is anointed

The most common error in succession work is promoting the name that has been in the building longest without asking how it compares with what is available outside. A loyal deputy who has waited eight years can be a fine successor. It is still worth knowing, before the board commits, what the external market would offer for the same role.

External benchmarking does not mean a full search. It means a confidential conversation with someone who knows the market, to say who exists, what they would cost and how the internal candidate looks beside them. Boards that do this are usually relieved. Either the internal candidate is confirmed, with a stronger case for the appointment, or the board learns early that the gap is wider than it thought and has time to close it.

JOH Partners' interview guide on the deputy chief executive interview describes what a board tests when a deputy is the leading candidate. In the podcast conversation with Santi Rasanayagam on moving from chief financial officer to chief executive, the question is how a finance leader becomes an operator, which is the gap many boards discover too late when the chief financial officer is the obvious successor.

When the bench is empty, a search is the fallback. In the engagement that placed the first non-family chief executive into a $3 billion Saudi industrial group, the search was successful, and it was also a reminder that the right moment to learn the bench is thin is before the vacancy.

Who owns the bench

The ownership questions are easier to answer than they look, provided the board does answer them.

The board owns the process and signs off the critical roles list. The nomination committee reviews the plan each year and holds the procedure for a vacancy; its wider job is covered in JOH Partners' perspective on the nomination committee in Gulf boards. The chief executive proposes the names for the roles beneath, since no one else knows the team as well. The chief people officer keeps the evidence and the ratings. The chair is the person who should be able to say, without notes, who covers each critical role if it fell vacant tomorrow.

The chair and chief executive handover is a different and harder subject, particularly in a family group, and it is the subject of JOH Partners' perspective on chair and chief executive transition. The point here is the layer beneath it. A chief executive who has a strong bench is easier to replace, and easier to retain, because the best people can see a path.

Seeing the bench between meetings

A plan that is reviewed once a year is better than one reviewed never, but a year is a long time in a group that is growing. People leave, divisions are restructured, a regulator changes what a role must carry. Boards that want to see the state of the senior layer between formal reviews, who has moved, which roles have lost their cover, where the ratings have slipped, use tools such as Board Pulse for a continuing view. The tool is less important than the discipline: a short, regular look at the same few questions, in the same format, so a change is visible when it happens. This is the same logic as JOH Partners' work on the first hundred days of a new chair, where the firm argues that what a board sees early is what it can still change.

The cost of finding out late

A board that discovers on the day of a resignation that it has no cover for a critical role pays in three ways. It pays in time, because a search for a senior executive in the Gulf takes months, and the interim period is run by whoever happens to be available. It pays in price, because the market knows when a group is in a hurry. And it pays in confidence, because the executives beneath the vacancy see that the board had no view of them, and the most mobile ones begin to look elsewhere.

None of these costs is large in the year the plan is written. They are large in the year it is needed. For a board in a group holding with several businesses and one or two people on whom everything depends, a few hours each year is cheap insurance. The first step is to write down the five or six roles that matter most and put three names beside each.


Key takeaways


JOH Partners is an executive search and senior executive recruitment firm advising chairs, nomination committees and family groups on succession and senior appointments across the GCC, the UK and Singapore. Boards that want continuing sight of their executive bench can request a Board Pulse demo, and a chair who would like a confidential view of how an internal candidate compares with the market can engage a partner.

Frequently asked questions

Questions about this topic.

What is succession planning for the executive committee?

It is the board's plan for who covers, who steps in and who is being prepared for each critical role beneath the chief executive, including the chief financial officer, chief operating officer, general counsel and the heads of the largest businesses. A real plan names people for three different situations: an emergency, an interim period and a planned handover, and it is refreshed at least once a year.

Do Gulf governance rules require a succession plan?

The Saudi Capital Market Authority's Corporate Governance Regulations, in the English translation reviewed, ask the board to develop succession plans for the management of the company and ask each board member to take part in developing succession and replacement plans for executive positions. They also ask the nomination committee to set the procedures to follow when a senior executive position falls vacant. Other Gulf codes should be read in their current text.

How many names should a board hold for each critical role?

At least three, for three different purposes: someone who could cover in an emergency, someone who could act as interim for up to a year, and someone being prepared for the permanent role. They can overlap, but a board that holds only one name for a role has a hope, not a plan.

How often should a board review succession for senior executives?

At least once a year, in a session with the chief executive, the chief people officer and the chair, with a shorter check at each meeting where a change has occurred. A review held only when someone resigns is a recruitment brief, not a plan.

Who owns succession below the chief executive?

The board owns the process, the nomination committee reviews it, the chief executive proposes the names for the roles beneath, and the chief people officer keeps the evidence. The chair should be able to say, without notes, who covers each critical role if it fell vacant tomorrow.

Author

Oliver Helvin

Founder and Managing Director

Oliver Helvin is the Founder and Managing Director of JOH Partners. He writes on the GCC executive market, leadership transitions in family-controlled businesses, and the discipline of senior search.

LinkedIn ↗