Executive Search Interview: What the Consultant Is Testing
An executive search interview is the first test of a senior move. How a search consultant weighs you, what reaches the client, and how to prepare.
Subscribe to our newsletter
A standing brief on the executive search and leadership market across the Gulf.
An executive search interview is not a job interview, and the executives who treat it as one tend to misjudge it. JOH Partners is itself an executive search firm and sits on the consultant's side of this conversation, so this guide describes what the consultant is weighing while you speak. It is written for senior candidates, from director level to the chair of a board, who have been approached about an appointment or who are about to meet a search firm for the first time. It explains what the consultant is testing, what reaches the client, and how to prepare for an executive search interview so that the call helps you.
It belongs with the board-level interview guides, and it comes before the later rounds described in facing the panel.
What is an executive search interview, and who is it really for?
It is a conversation of roughly an hour, by phone, by video or in a meeting room, between you and a consultant who is working for a client on one appointment. The client pays the firm. The candidate does not. That fact explains most of what follows: the consultant is working for the client, and a good consultant also treats you honestly, because a poor appointment damages the firm's reputation with both of you.
The consultant is not deciding whether to hire you. They are deciding whether to put you in front of a client, with their name attached to the recommendation. In a retained search the shortlist is the product. If a candidate on it falls apart in the first client meeting, the consultant's judgement is what the client questions.
So the interview is for the client, even though you are the one in the room. Assume that what you say will be written down and summarised. The note the client reads about you is often the first thing the client sees.
A search consultant is not interviewing you for a job. They are deciding whether to put their own name behind you in front of a client.
How does a search consultant decide whether to put you forward?
Three questions run in the consultant's mind, whatever they ask aloud. Can you do the job? Will the client want you? And will you see the process through?
The first is about substance. The consultant has a brief from the client, and they are testing your experience against it. They will probe the parts of your record that the brief depends on, such as who you reported to, how large the team and budget were, and what you were personally responsible for.
The second is about fit with the client. A consultant who has met the chair knows things about the client that are not in the brief: how the board makes decisions, what happened to the last appointee, what kind of person the principal trusts. They are listening for whether you are that kind of person, and they are allowed to say so to you only in part.
The third question is the one candidates overlook. A late withdrawal costs the client weeks and costs the consultant credibility. So the consultant tests commitment. Are you interested in this role, or in being asked? Would you take it if offered? Is your family aware? What would your current employer do to keep you? Honest answers are far better here than polished enthusiasm, because a candidate who admits uncertainty early can be helped, and one who withdraws late cannot.
What will the consultant ask about your career story?
Expect to be asked to walk through your career move by move, and to say why you made each one. The consultant is looking for a line: a reason you went from one role to the next that you can state without effort. If each move needs a new explanation, the line is missing.
Be ready for the awkward moves. A short tenure, a change of sector, a role that did not go as planned: these will come up, and the consultant wants a plain account they can repeat to the client without embarrassment. The same applies to your last exit, which is covered in more detail in why did you leave your last job.
Consider also what you ask in return. Ask how your details will be shared and when. A reputable firm will not send your CV to a client without your agreement, and it should tell you plainly who will see it. Do not be shy about asking.
A cross-border career raises its own questions, such as why you moved, how long you intend to stay in a region, and what your family situation is. Adam Malouf on cross-border leadership across Dubai, Australia and beyond is a useful listen for anyone whose story has to carry several countries.
Should you talk about money in the first call?
Yes, and fully. The consultant will ask what you earn today, including base, bonus, long-term incentives, benefits and any allowances, and what you would need to move. They are not collecting the figures to use against you. They need them because a search in which the candidate and the client are far apart wastes everyone's time.
Give accurate numbers and say what is guaranteed and what is not. Do not exaggerate. The figures may be tested later, when an offer is made, and a mismatch at that stage does lasting damage. If you are unsure what your package is worth, work it out before the call. Negotiating an executive job offer goes into how a package is read at the offer stage, and it is worth reading before you speak to anyone.
You do not have to name a precise number on the first call. A range, with the reasons behind it, is reasonable: "I would want to move to something in this region, depending on the long-term incentive." What counts is that you sound as though you have thought about it and are not inventing a figure as you speak.
What should you ask the consultant?
The consultant is a source of information about the client, and the quality of your questions shows how you would behave in the client's room. Ask why the role is open, and whether it is new or a replacement. Ask who the role reports to, and who sits on the panel. Ask what the client most wants this person to change in the first year, and what has not worked so far. Ask what the timetable is, and how the client intends to decide. The thirteen-week mandate describes a typical search from the client's side, which helps you understand where you are in the sequence.
A consultant will not tell you everything, and a good one will tell you when they cannot answer. Take the silence as information too. If every question about the previous appointee gets a vague reply, ask the client directly when you meet them.
One more question deserves a place: how will you hear back, and when? A good consultant gives feedback after each stage, including when the answer is no. Ask for it, and ask for candid feedback and not a courtesy reply. The best candidates use the consultant as a source of honest comment on how they came across.
Is the consultant on your side?
Not entirely, and it is better to understand why. The consultant acts for the client, and will not argue your case over the client's interests. But a good consultant wants you appointed if you are the right person, wants you to arrive well prepared, and wants the appointment to last. Within those limits they are often the most useful ally you have, and they will tell you things that an employer will not.
Use that. Ask how the client's senior team has behaved in earlier searches. Ask what a successful candidate looked like last time. Ask for a view on where you are weakest against the brief, and what you could do about it before the first client meeting.
Treat the relationship as longer than one search. Consultants remember who was direct, who prepared and who withdrew without notice. A search is often won or lost on a call you took two years earlier for a role you did not want. Retained executive search in the GCC describes how these searches are run in the region, which helps you see the process from the client's chair. For the client's view of a completed search, an anonymised search for a chief executive of a Saudi industrial group is a useful companion, and group holdings shows the sector where this kind of search is common.
Treat the first call as the start of the process, not the warm-up. What you say there is often what the client reads next.
How do you prepare so the call helps you?
Prepare as you would for a meeting with the client, but expect a conversation and not an examination. Have your career story ready in about three minutes. Know your package to the last allowance. Decide in advance what would make you say yes to a move, and what would make you say no. Think about who else is likely to have been approached, and why you should be on the shortlist and not them.
Then say honestly what you are not sure about. Candidates are often afraid that doubt looks weak. In practice a consultant is relieved to hear it, because it tells them where to help.
AssessYou is the candidate platform from JOH Partners, and the free your story interview question bank on AssessYou, with how to approach each question and example answers includes "Talk me through the rationale behind each of your career moves", the question a search consultant will almost certainly ask. All the free banks are listed at assess-you.com/interview-questions, with no sign-in needed. When you are ready to practise on your own CV with candid feedback on every answer, sign up to AssessYou.
The consultant's first call is brief, and most of the work in it is done before it starts. Take it at a time you can speak freely, with your career laid out in front of you, and answer as you would to a client you hope to work with for years.
Questions about the executive search interview.
What is an executive search interview?
It is the first conversation between a senior candidate and a search consultant who is working for a client on a specific appointment. The consultant is deciding whether to put you forward on a shortlist, and your answers are usually summarised for the client. It is a screening interview, but it carries real weight, because the client often reads the consultant's note before meeting you.
Who pays the search firm, the candidate or the client?
The client pays. A reputable executive search firm does not charge candidates. That is why the consultant's loyalty in the process is to the client, even though a good consultant treats candidates fairly and wants an appointment that lasts.
Should you discuss your current pay with a search consultant?
Yes, honestly and in full, including bonus, long-term incentives and benefits. The consultant needs an accurate picture to avoid wasting your time and the client's. State what you earn today and what you would need to move. Exaggerating your package is risky, because the client may later see the figures when an offer is made.
Can you contact the client directly while a search is running?
You should not. Going around the consultant usually damages your standing with both. If you already know someone at the client, tell the consultant at the start so the situation is clear. Ask questions about the role, the timetable and the decision-makers through the consultant, who is the channel the client has chosen.
What should you do if the consultant calls about a role that is not right for you?
Say so promptly and give a reason, then offer to help. You can suggest a name or tell the consultant what would make you reconsider. Consultants remember candidates who were direct and useful, and they remember the ones who were not. A polite no today often leads to a better call later.
Oliver Helvin
Founder and Managing Director
Oliver Helvin is the Founder and Managing Director of JOH Partners. He writes on the GCC executive market, leadership transitions in family-controlled businesses, and the discipline of senior search.
LinkedIn ↗